Here's the link
The old defenses are being trotted out again. Like much else that used to sound like common sense, they have a tinny, clueless ring in present circumstances. The separation of art and artist is proclaimed — rather desperately, it seems to me — as if it were a philosophical principle, rather than a cultural habit buttressed by shopworn academic dogma. But the notion that art belongs to a zone of human experience somehow distinct from other human experiences is both conceptually incoherent and intellectually crippling. Art belongs to life, and anyone — critic, creator or fan — who has devoted his or her life to art knows as much.
Furthermore, Mr. Allen’s art in particular is saturated with his personality, his preoccupations, his biography and his tastes. One of the most powerful illusions encouraged by popular art is that its creators are people the rest of us know. This is not only because tales of their childhoods and news of their marriages and divorces feed our prurient appetites, or because we can peek into their lives on Instagram and Twitter. It’s also because they carry intimate baggage into their work and invite us to sort through the contents.
This is the blog of the Arts Reviewing and Reporting Class Spring 2018 at the University of San Francisco. As Oscar Wilde wrote, “To the critic, the work of art is simply a suggestion for a new work of his own.”
Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Review
Our Class Blogs
Friday, February 2, 2018
NYTimes Film Critic Wrestles with the Woody Allen Problem
Labels:
A.O. Scott,
Woody Allen
J. Michael Robertson directs the journalism program in the Department of Media Studies at the University of San Francisco. He was an editor/staff writer at the San Francisco Chronicle, 1980-1991, and Atlanta Magazine, 1976-1980. He received a Ph.D. in English Literature from Duke University in 1972.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Building Vocabulary
Reviewing Books
Reviewing Drama
Reviewing the Fine Arts
Reviewing Restaurants
A More Academic Approach
Big Critics
Reviewing Music
Followers
Blog Archive
-
▼
2018
(71)
-
▼
February
(22)
- Manohla Dargis
- Some Points I Wanted to Make...
- Maybe My Favorite New Critic
- A Review of Hansel and Gretel with Comments from 2013
- A Thoughtful Quote from a Review of a New Movie
- The 60s Generation Sharing a TV Theme Song in an I...
- Getting Gangnam Style
- A Rhetorical Analysis of Lost Dog
- Pete Wells
- Parul Seghal
- Wesley Morris
- Laura Snapes
- The Twitter Panel Reviews Vicky Cristina Barcelona
- Taylor Swift Sued But the Song Lyrics Too 'Banal' ...
- And, Of Course, Satire
- I Add Something to My Thoughts about Comedy and La...
- TV Critics Tend to Avoid Popular Shows
- Quick Takes on Oscar Nominees for Best Picture
- You Are Watching Less *Live* TV
- The Sitcom Formula
- NYTimes Film Critic Wrestles with the Woody Allen ...
- My Sitcom Bullet Points
-
▼
February
(22)
No comments:
Post a Comment