Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Review

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Some Points I Wanted to Make...

Eddie Izzard
Eddie Izzard (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
 ... as I graded your sitcom reviews.

1) I did want you to tell me the names of the actors who played the various parts and possibly to tell me other shows they appeared in. The point of that in this case would be to make clear the key participants in this project were all vets of film and TV, suggesting (among other things) that money was probably invested in this project upfront. These people had records of previous success. As flops go, this was a big one.

2) Also, talking about the careers of the actors provides a natural transition either out of or into a discussion of the acting.

3) But how would you know what these actors did earlier in their careers? I did NOT intend to use Turnitin as a bludgeon to discourage you from doing *any* research. A quick Google to discover who is this Eddie Izzard is acceptable - and won't ruin your T score anymore than using Google to find out the hours of the restaurants you reviewed. What I *don't* want you to do is use the internet to read reviews by others and turn your own review into a compilation rather than a fresh take.

4) Take a look at this review from the Chronicle that I linked to on the class blog several years ago. It's not great, but you see how David Wiegand has a catchy little lead that makes clear his focus. This review has a good old-fashioned thesis!! And then he lets us know who in the cast does what and what there backgrounds are. I actually think he puts all this info too high in the review. But notice how about 2/3rds in, he gives rich detail about the excellence of the detail in the background animation. Most reviews are a mixture of supported and unsupported generalizations. If you richly and persuasively support *some* of your generalizations, readers are more likely to take your unsupported ones on faith.

https://www.sfgate.com/default/article/BoJack-Horseman-review-Saddled-with-mediocre-5698929.php


Maybe My Favorite New Critic

The Looming Tower
The Looming Tower (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
His name is Todd VanDerWerff

But then Chesney zeroes in on the suspect in a way that twists the conversation so slowly toward accusation and ultimately confession that you almost don’t realize it’s happened. Why is there blood on the suspect’s hands but not on his clothes if he didn’t completely change his outfit? Why’s the price tag still on his belt? By the time Chesney is shouting and pounding on the table between the two men to extract viable intelligence (the phone number of an al-Qaeda higher-up), the scene has spiraled in on itself so skillfully that the audience has been manipulated just as much as the suspect.

A lot of this works because of Camp, who’s masterful in the part. And just as much is thanks to director John Dahl, who gives a scene that’s just two men talking in a room a sense of pace and excitement that’s inescapable. (I love how often he pins his camera on one of the two men as the other is talking, to judge their reactions as they try to figure out what they’re going to say next to achieve their goals.) And, sure, much of it is informed by the fact that we in the audience know Chesney and his cohorts won’t be successful in stopping the big attack that’s coming. Indeed, if you’ve read the book, you know one of the characters will die in that very attack.

But I really appreciate how writer Bash Doran didn’t push too hard with this scene. She simply let it play out like an interrogation scene you’ve seen in many other cop dramas, as the two men circle each other warily and look for weakness. The Looming Tower gains strength from its familiarity, from the way it engages with how cop dramas can use their workaday characters and scenarios to talk about issues that impact society as a whole. More recent police procedurals, which are far more rigid in how they think about solving a case per week, have lost sight of that just a bit. The Looming Tower, by virtue of its ultimate endpoint, knows that every case solved just leads to more suspects to track down.

Tuesday, February 27, 2018

A Review of Hansel and Gretel with Comments from 2013

Series for social welfare 1961, fairy tale of ...
Series for social welfare 1961, fairy tale of the brothers Grimm, Hansel and Gretel :*Ausgabepreis: 20+10 Pfennig :*First Day of Issue / Erstausgabetag: 2. Oktober 1961 :*Michel-Katalog-Nr.: 371 (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
I have a Google alert that pushes a variety of reviews at me. I arbitrarily grabbed the first one in a recent push from the Woburn Journal, a newspaper in Massachusetts.

 Hansel and Gretel: Witch Hunters Grade: ** | Posted: Tuesday, February 12, 2013 12:08 pm Produced by Will Ferrell's company, UH-OH. THE PARTICIPLE ‘PRODUCED’ MODIFIES ‘YOU.’ NOT A GOOD START you can't be blamed for thinking that 'Hansel and Gretel: Witch Hunters', update on the famous fairy tale of the brother and sister, who escaped the clutches of a witch by burning her up in an oven, would be a straight comedy. THIS COULD BE RIGHT. CAN I FEEL CONFIDENT THE SMALL-TOWN REVIEWER KNOWS WHAT OTHER FILMS WF HAS PRODUCED? The film does contain its fair share of laughs, but coupled with the director's style, which seems anchored by the notion that there's enough blood in any scene, REWRITE THE PREVIOUS. THINK I GET IT BUT HAD TO STOP AND CONSIDER the movie ends up being a disjointed mess. OKAY. HE’S SET UP THE ‘DISJOINTED’ BY SUGGESTING THE MOVIE CONTAINS SOME LAUGHS AND TOO MUCH BLOOD. THE REVIEW HAS A FOCUS

The story, which is sprinkled liberally with anachronisms and gizmos, GOOD POINT begins with the young siblings being led into the woods by their father and deserted there together. LOSE THE ‘TOGETHER.’ The two, naturally, IS THIS HIS WAY OF SUGGESTING FAIRYTALES AREN’T REALISTIC? DUH. stumble into a cottage made of candy, where a ghastly witch imprisons them. They figure out early on how to kill a witch - you need to burn her. And as they save their own lives, they begin a career as witch hunters. ‘AS’? RIGHT FROM THAT MINUTE?

 Their latest assignment is from the mayor of Augsburg - Figure out who is kidnapping local children. Jeremy Renner (“The Bourne Legacy”) is a great actor REALLY? I DIDN’T KNOW THE CRITICAL WORLD HAD COME TO THAT CONCLUSION, and he gives his Hansel character such a tongue-in-cheek approach that you can’t help but like him. THIS JUDGMENT WORKS FOR ME Gemma Arterton (“Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time”) is his resourceful, no-nonsense sister Gretel. YOU’VE JUDGED HIS ACTING. HOW ABOUT HER’S? Both carry high-powered weaponry (for the period in which this is set, that is) and are expert shots. She carries a sort of automatic crossbow and he carries a kind of arm cannon.

 There are no surprises, unless you count the troll, OKAY. THERE’S A TROLL COMING BUT THE SURPRISE IS NOT COMPLETELY SPOILED as this is a straightforward exercise of pursuit and deduction with the siblings figuring out that the lost children are being prepared for a rite to be performed on the night of the blood moon. That night, all the witches in attendance will be rendered fireproof, something the head of the coven, Muriel (Famke Janssen), wants desperately to see happen. LOTS OF PLOT. NOT SURE I WANT TO KNOW QUITE THIS MUCH. NOW ALL WE HAVE LEFT TO IMAGINE IS THE EXACT NATURE OF HER DEFEAT.

 The film 'DOES TAKE' WOULD REFLECT IDEA OF HUMOR ALREADY INTRODUCED takes many stabs at humor along the way. Hansel is a diabetic, as he has been hooked on sugar since his first encounter with the witch's house made of candy, FUNNY while woodcut portraits of the missing children attached to bottles of milk can't help but make you laugh. OKAY. TOOK ME THREE READS TO UNDERSTAND THE PRECEDING; REWRITE, PLEASE; I THOUGH HE MEANT PORTRAITS OF CHILDREN SHOWING THEM ATTACHED TO MILK BOTTLES…

 Don't even bring up the odd variety of witches seen during the film's climax. The Siamese twins who can kill you with their ninja moves have to be seen to be believed. THE TWO PRECEDING SENTENCES AREN’T PARTICULARY WELL WRITTEN. I HOPE THE TWO CLICHES JUMP OUT.

 The film is like pollen in the spring - all over the place, and doesn't do anyone much good. KIND OF NICE? CREDIT WHERE CREDIT IS DUE Renner and Arterton are good sports throughout, playing things straight in a film they must have had reservations about, TYPICAL COMMENT IN REVIEWS: ACTORS MUST HAVE FIGURED OUT AT SOME POINT THIS WAS A BAD PROJECT while Janssen is perfectly cast, bringing the right combination of menace and sexiness to the role. She admitted in a recent interview that the only reason she took the part was to pay for a new kitchen. GOOD KNOWLEDGE

 If I can say anything positive about “Hansel & Gretel” it’s that it at least looks cool. The action scenes are pure visual spectacle. THERE’S LAZY WRITING, AND THERE’S GOOD WRITING. THE REVIEWER HAS ALREADY SAID SOME POSITIVE THINGS. HE NEEDS TO TWEAK HIS “IF’ CLAUSE
Enhanced by Zemanta

Friday, February 23, 2018

A Thoughtful Quote from a Review of a New Movie

The Best Science Fiction Stories: 1952
The Best Science Fiction Stories: 1952 (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
The reviewer is Alissa Wilkinson, writing for Vox.


That the expedition is populated by five women, played by five stellar actresses — it’s hard to pick a standout — adds a startling depth to the film. Instead of seeing an exploration of desire through the more typically male filter that often drives thrillers, action, science fiction, and horror, we see it through female eyes. And that makes each piece feel fresh and unexpected.

In fact, though its parallels to Stalker are undeniable and Garland has an established track record in the science-fiction genre, Annihilation feels wholly unexpected and raw. It is a disturbing film for reasons that are almost metaphysical. It rarely moves quickly, the camera lingering over images that are hard to forget because they’re so eerie, the story leaving just enough unexplained to evoke mystery and wonder.

Thursday, February 22, 2018

The 60s Generation Sharing a TV Theme Song in an Ironic Way



Stanley Kubrick's Full Metal Jacket is, as one critic put it, a tale of "relentless discomfort and (the) complicated morality" of the war in Vietnam and perhaps a masterpiece. Is the final scene of the movie a comment on a generation united but infantile as the unit's depleted ranks walk away from the killing grounds of Hue?

Whatever the larger point, they all know the lyrics.

Getting Gangnam Style

Burger King, Seoul, South Korea.
Burger King, Seoul, South Korea. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Here is an analysis of Gangnam Style drawing on familiarity with the language and culture.

 "I have to admit I've watched it about 15 times," said a CNN anchor. "Of course, no one here in the U.S. has any idea what Psy is rapping about."

I certainly didn't, beyond the basics: Gangnam is a tony Seoul neighborhood, and Park's "Gangnam Style" video lampoons its self-importance and ostentatious wealth, with Psy playing a clownish caricature of a Gangnam man. That alone makes it practically operatic compared to most K-Pop. But I spoke with two regular observers of Korean culture to find out what I was missing, and it turns out that the video is rich with subtle references that, along with the song itself, suggest a subtext with a surprisingly subversive message about class and wealth in contemporary South Korean society. 

This type of analysis suggests several points:

1) In your reviews, I want you to do as little research as possible. (That's why I run all your reviews through Turnitin.) I want a fresh personal take in which you draw on what you already know - though if it happens you already know a great deal about the genre or the specific situations in the object reviewed, of course you draw on it. Some publications might want you to do research beforehand and create a combined review/cultural analysis. What I want is your "hot take." Personally, though I wanted at some point to do research and to track down the kind of analysis of the video contained in the Atlantic that I link to above, I wanted to take time to register my own reactions and my own reading of the video before seeking out informed interpretation.

2) I assume a natural inhibition in reviewing something like Gangnam Style because it is our wish - I hope your wish - not to seem culturally ignorant or racially insensitive. With all that in mind, my first take on the video was:

     * The music was catchy, what some would call an earworm, memorable to the point of irritation.

     * The music alone did not explain the video's appeal. Without the images and/or narrative, the music would quickly have faded from memory.

     * I was amused and impressed by Psy's comic physicality, by which I mean his posture and actions were awkwardly graceful - or gracefully awkward. I was comfortable judging that part of the video by what I considered to be widespread ideas concerning which styles of physical action are funny and which aren't - at least by Western standards - and the makers of the video seemed to understand the conventions of the music video as developed in the United States.

     * I appreciated the general technical mastery - the multiple cuts, the careful framing of shots, the choreography of dance and motion.

     * It did have a narrative through line. Psy falls in love, or at least in "like." Are we invited to judge the nature of that attraction? The young woman's blond hair seemed to invite judgment.

     * But I still felt at a loss in terms of getting all the themes and implications. I was not surprised to learn it was probably satire, but if I had learned that its creator thought it was a celebration of sexual freedom and material possessions, well, I would have been somewhat surprised - but not completely. Not to get too English Major-ish, there's a famous comment by the poet John Keats. “At once it struck me, what quality went to form a Man of Achievement, especially in literature, and which Shakespeare possessed so enormously. I mean Negative Capability, that is when man is capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason.” I like to interpret this from a critic’s point of view to mean that a sense of fully getting a work of art is not desirable. A true work of art - the pundit said - is a mystery that we never quite solve.

      * The video made we want to initiate conversations with those whom I assumed were its target audience, you guys maybe? That is, I saw it as a kind of measuring stick against which I could evaluate differences in taste as determined by different class and age.

      * And, of course, when in doubt when it comes to music videos, we can fall back on the surreal by which I simply mean regarding image or images as dream-like and irrational. Why ask what it means when I can ask what does it mean to me? Was it not Freud - it was; I looked it up - who said, “What is common in all these dreams is obvious. They completely satisfy wishes excited during the day which remain unrealized. They are simply and undisguisedly realizations of wishes.”

      * The fact the video was for about two years the most watched video on Youtube has to mean something about the universality of ... something.





-->



A Rhetorical Analysis of Lost Dog

Wednesday, February 21, 2018

Pete Wells

Pete Wells is one of The New York Times main restaurant/food reviewers; he's one of the "big guns" in the reviewing world. His review of Guy Fieri's restaurant has been dubbed "the most widely read food review ever." Wells is a gifted writer and conscious of more than just whats on his plate. Here is an excerpt from his recent review of "Salt Bae's" new eatery, Nusr-Et.

"A few years ago, restaurants were still a refuge from the electronic grid, places where we could eat and talk without converting existence into digital form. Phone cameras changed that, and now it often seems that the point of going out to eat is to post a digital image proving we were there."

Parul Seghal

"There’s not a trace of piety, however. “Mean” calls for a fat, fluorescent trigger warning start to finish — and I say this admiringly. Gurba likes the feel of radioactive substances on her bare hands. She wants to find new angles from which to report on this most ancient of stories, to zap you into feeling." - Parul Seghal

Wesley Morris

"Who would have thought that a series addicted to the high of movement could also summon a solemnity that leaves you moved?"‐ Wesley Morris

Followers